Incorrect customs charges are more common than many shippers realise. Goods may be misclassified, valued incorrectly, or denied a preferential tariff rate they are entitled to. When this happens, you have the right to dispute the charge — but the process varies by country and must typically be followed within strict deadlines.
This guide explains the most common reasons customs charges are incorrect, how to identify an error, and the steps involved in disputing a charge in the EU and UK.
Common Reasons for Incorrect Customs Charges
- Wrong HS code applied, resulting in a higher duty rate than the correct classification
- Goods misidentified as not originating in a country with a preferential trade agreement, so the standard rate was applied instead of zero
- Incorrect customs valuation (value declared correctly but customs used a different value)
- Goods returned to their country of origin incorrectly treated as new imports
- Administrative errors — wrong reference numbers, mismatched quantities
Before You Dispute: Gather Your Evidence
Before filing a formal dispute, collect: the original commercial invoice and customs entry reference number, the goods' correct HS code and evidence for why that code is correct, any proof of origin documents (supplier declarations, EUR.1 certificates), and the customs authority's decision notice showing what they applied and why.
Disputing a Customs Charge in the EU
In EU member states, customs decisions can be challenged under Article 44 of the Union Customs Code (UCC). The process typically involves:
- Administrative review: a formal written objection to the customs office that issued the decision. This must typically be lodged within 30 days of the decision in most EU member states (deadlines vary by country, so check your national customs authority's rules).
- Judicial review: if the administrative review is unsuccessful, you can appeal to a national court or tribunal.
In Portugal, formal customs appeals are submitted to the customs office that issued the determination, with subsequent appeals to the AT (Autoridade Tributária e Aduaneira).
Disputing a Customs Charge in the UK
In the UK, customs disputes are handled by HMRC. You can challenge a customs decision by: asking for a review by HMRC (you must request this within 30 days of the decision), or appealing to the Tax and Chancery Chamber of the First-tier Tribunal. HMRC's online service allows you to request a decision review or submit duty deferral claims.
Common Questions
Should I pay the disputed amount while the appeal is in progress?
In most cases, your carrier requires payment to release the goods before the appeal is resolved. Pay under protest and note in writing that payment is made without prejudice to your appeal rights. Document everything. If your appeal is successful, you should receive a refund of the disputed amount.
Can my customs broker handle the appeal?
Yes. A licensed customs broker can represent you in customs disputes and appeals. For complex cases involving significant duty amounts, using a broker or customs law specialist is advisable.




